Can You Sue a Private or Faith-Based School for Sexual Abuse in Pennsylvania?
When a child is harmed at a private or faith-based school, the survivor and their family deserve answers, and they deserve accountability. A civil claim is separate from any criminal case. Police can charge the abuser, but a civil claim lets the survivor and their family hold both that person and the private or religious school responsible and recover compensation. You do not need a criminal conviction, or even a criminal case, to move forward, and a school’s private or religious status does not place it above the law. Families often choose a private or faith-based school precisely because they trust its values and its promise to look after their children closely. But these schools can operate with less outside oversight than public districts, and a strong instinct to protect the institution’s name and donors. When that instinct wins out over a child’s safety, when a school hides a complaint or quietly moves an abuser along, a civil claim is frequently the only way the truth comes out. It is often the only thing that forces a school to change.Who Can Be Held Legally Responsible for Private-School Abuse?
The abuser is responsible for what they did. Many times, the private school, religious school, or the organization or diocese behind it is also liable, and it usually has the resources to provide meaningful compensation. A Pennsylvania private or faith-based school can be held responsible when it was negligent in ways such as:- Hiring without proper checks: employing a teacher, coach, clergy member, or staffer without adequate background screening, or despite a record of concerning behavior.
- Failing to supervise: allowing one adult to be alone with a student, ignoring inappropriate conduct, or not providing oversight during activities and trips.
- Keeping someone on after warnings: retaining a staff member following complaints, a prior incident, or clear warning signs.
- Failing to report: not reporting suspected child abuse as Pennsylvania’s mandated-reporter law requires of private-school staff.
- Covering up complaints: handling reports internally to protect the school’s reputation, or quietly allowing an abuser to resign or transfer.
Types of Private and Faith-Based School Abuse Cases We Handle
Survivors of Abuse PA represents students and families in cases involving sexual abuse at private and parochial schools across Pennsylvania, including independent day schools, religious and parochial schools, and academies. We handle cases involving abuse by teachers, coaches, clergy, aides, and other staff, as well as student-on-student abuse that the school failed to prevent. (Clergy-specific cases may also fall under clergy abuse.) If you are unsure whether what happened counts, it costs nothing to ask.Understanding Your Deadline to File in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania has specific deadlines that have changed in recent years, so the safest step is to confirm yours directly. Pennsylvania law has expanded the time childhood sexual-abuse survivors have to bring a civil claim, and the deadline depends on the survivor’s age, when the abuse happened, and other facts that have been the subject of ongoing reform. Even abuse from years ago may still be within the deadline, and waiting can forfeit the right to file. A free, confidential call with Ashley DiLiberto gives you a clear, accurate answer about your specific situation, at no cost and no obligation.What to Do If You Think a Child Is Being Abused
If a child is in immediate danger, call 911. To report suspected child abuse in Pennsylvania, contact ChildLine, the state’s child-abuse hotline, at 1-800-932-0313 (available 24/7). You do not have to go through the school’s or the church’s internal process first. For confidential support, the RAINN National Sexual Assault Hotline is available 24/7 at 1-800-656-4673. When you are ready, a civil attorney can explain your family’s options privately and at no cost.Compensation in a Private-School Abuse Case
A civil claim can seek compensation for things like counseling and future therapy, medical care, the impact on a child’s education, pain and suffering, and the lasting harm to a young life. Many cases also lead to real change in how a school screens staff, supervises students, and handles reports, helping to protect other children in the process. Survivors of Abuse PA handles these cases on a contingency basis, meaning there is no cost to you unless we win. Past results never guarantee a future outcome; each case is judged on its own facts.Frequently asked questions
Can you sue a private or religious school for sexual abuse in Pennsylvania?
Yes. A school being private or faith-based does not put it above the law. When it enabled abuse — through negligent hiring, poor supervision, ignored complaints, failure to report, or a cover-up — it can be held financially responsible in a civil lawsuit, separate from any criminal case. You do not need a criminal conviction to file.
How is a private-school case different from a public-school case?
The core duties are similar, but private and faith-based schools often operate with less outside oversight and different responsible parties — a religious order, diocese, or board behind the school. The legal rules can differ too. An attorney can identify which entities are responsible in your situation.
What if a priest or clergy member at the school abused my child?
You may have a claim against both the school and the religious institution behind it, and the case may also involve clergy-abuse principles. Cases like these often focus on what the diocese or order knew and how it responded. An attorney can pursue every responsible party.
Do private-school staff have to report suspected abuse?
Yes. Pennsylvania's mandated-reporter law applies to private and parochial school staff. A school's failure to report — or its choice to handle a complaint quietly instead — can be part of a civil claim against it.
What if the school handled it internally and asked us not to go public?
You are not bound by that. Handling abuse internally to protect a school's reputation is often part of the problem, not a resolution. Speaking with an independent attorney before agreeing to anything helps you understand your rights and avoid giving them up.
Can I still bring a claim if the abuse was years ago?
You may be able to. Pennsylvania has expanded the time childhood sexual-abuse survivors have to bring a civil claim, and even older abuse may still be within the deadline depending on the facts. A free, confidential call can confirm where you stand.
Who do I call to report suspected abuse at a private school?
If a child is in immediate danger, call 911. To report suspected child abuse, contact ChildLine, the state's 24/7 hotline, at 1-800-932-0313. You do not have to use the school's internal process first. For confidential support, RAINN is available 24/7 at 1-800-656-4673.
How long do I have to file a private-school abuse lawsuit in Pennsylvania?
Pennsylvania's civil deadlines depend on the survivor's age, when the abuse happened, and other facts, and the rules have changed in recent years. Even older cases may still be within the deadline. Because a mistake can forfeit the claim, the safest step is a free, confidential call to confirm yours.
Will my family's case be kept private?
Your first conversation is confidential, and protecting a child's privacy is a priority throughout. Many abuse settlements are confidential. Ashley DiLiberto's practice is trauma-informed and survivor-centered — your family shares only what you are comfortable with, at your pace.
How much does a private-school abuse lawyer cost?
Nothing up front. These cases are handled on contingency — no fee unless we win — and the consultation is free and confidential. You should never have to pay out of pocket to learn whether your family has a case.
What type of lawyer handles private and faith-based school abuse cases?
These are civil cases handled by a sexual-abuse attorney experienced in holding institutions accountable. Ashley B. DiLiberto, Esq. is a Pennsylvania sexual-abuse lawyer and Partner at Messa & Associates whose record includes a leadership role in the $2.46 billion Boy Scouts of America settlement. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Serving sexual abuse survivors across Pennsylvania
Ashley DiLiberto represents survivors statewide. Explore help in your area:
